Our prior research revealed that there are 2 mitochondrial clades of Aphelinus mali (Haldeman) (Hymenoptera: Aphelinidae) in China, which are known as SD clade and LN clade. To further reveal their genetic characteristics and to determine the degrees of hybridization and gene flow between the 2 clades of A. mali in China, we analyzed the genetic diversities and genetic structures of 16 populations from 6 provinces (Shandong, Liaoning, Hebei, Shanxi, Xinjiang, and Yunnan) using 8 micro satellite loci. Our results showed that among the pure populations in the SD and LN clades, the greatest genetic diversities were found in the Qingdao, Shandong (QD) population and in the Dalian, Liaoning (DL) population. QD was the first population of the SD clade to be established, and DL was the first population of the LN clade to be established. In addition, genetic diversity was not substantially lower - and in some cases it was greater - in mixed-clade populations than in QD and DL. Individuals within each mitochondrial clade could not be differentiated based on microsatellite loci. Our data confirmed that the QD and DL populations, which were the first to be established in China, have served as bridgeheads for the other SD and LN populations in China. The results demonstrated that the hybridization or gene flow has occurred between the 2 mitochondrial clades.
Aphelinus mali (Haldeman) (Hymenoptera: aphid, Eriosoma lanigerum (Hausmann) (HemipAphelinidae), a parasitoid of the woolly apple tera: Aphididae) originated from North America (Beers 2012; Lavandero and Tylianakis 2013). Aphelinus mali was introduced into 51 countries during the 20th century to control E. lanigerum, and this parasitoid successfully established populations in 42 of these countries (Zhou et al. 2010).
Aphelinus mali was introduced as an endoparasitoid of E. lanigerum in China during the 1940s-1960s. The first introduction involved the importation of A. mali from Japan to Dalian, Liaoning in 1942 (Long et al. 1960). It was reintroduced from the former Soviet Union into Qingdao, Shandong during 1953–1955 (Long et al. 1960). Since then, A. mali has become established in most regions of China including Shandong, Liaoning, Shanxi, Yunnan, Hebei, Henan, and Xinjiang (Zhou et al. 2010; Zhang et al. 2014). Our field survey showed that all of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (mt COI) haplotypes grouped into 2 main clades, i.e., SD and LN. The SD clade was mainly distributed in Shandong and neighboring regions while the LN clade was mainly distributed in Liaoning and neighboring regions (Zhang et al. 2014). However, the genetic diversity and genetic structure of the A. mali in China based on nuclear markers have not been analyzed. Such investigations may provide knowledge of the hybridization and gene flow between the 2 clades of A. mali, which may be helpful in the control of the E. lanigerum in China. Currently, microsatellite markers have been extensively used in the analysis of genetic diversity and genetic structure (e.g., Ascunce et al. 2011; Chu et al. 2013; Dickey et al. 2013; Mwacharo et al. 2013).
Summary population genetics statistics calculated based on 8 microsatellites of 16 Aphelinus MALI POPULATIONS IN CHINA.
In this study, we analyzed the genetic diversity and genetic structure of 16 populations from 6 provinces (Shandong, Liaoning, Hebei, Shanxi, Xinjiang, and Yunnan) using 8 nuclear microsatellite loci. Based on these data, we wanted to reveal the genetic characteristics of the introduced populations of A. mali in China, and to determine the hybridization and gene flow within the 2 clades of A. mali in regions of China where they have been recently introduced.
Supporting material can be found online in Florida Entomologist 97(2) (June, 2014) at http://purl.fcla.edu/fcla/entomologist/browse.
Materials and Methods
Sample Collection and Species Identification
A total of 16 E. lanigerum populations were sampled from apple trees in 6 provinces in China during 2007, 2008, and 2012. They were placed in Petri dishes at room temperature until A. mali eclosed. Adult A. mali that emerged were examined and identified unambiguously with the aid of a microscope and were then stored in 95% ethanol at -20 °C until DNA extraction. The sampling location of each population is listed in Table 1.
DNA Extraction and Microsatellite Genotyping
Genomic DNA was extracted from individual female adults as described in Frohlich et al. (1999). The DNA of A. mali individuals and the PCR primers were used to amplify the microsatellite loci Aml3, Aml4, Aml9, Am27, Am34, Am35, Am36, and Am38 (Lavandero & Dominguez 2010). PCR reactions were performed as described by Lavandero & Dominguez (2010). Products were run on an ABI 3730xl DNA analyzer. Allele size was determined by comparing the mobility of the PCR products to that of the GeneScanTM 400HD size standard (Applied Biosystems).
Genetic Diversity Analysis
For the microsatellite data of each population, POPGENE vl.31 was used to calculate the following indices: the observed number of alleles (Na), the effective number of alleles (Ne), the expected heterozygosity (He), the observed heterozygosity (Ho), and Nei's expected heterozygosity (Nei) (Yeh et al. 1997). We determined these indices for both pure and mixed populations; pure populations were those that contained only one haplotype, and mixed populations were those that contained more than one haplotype (Table S1). For mixed populations, we also determined these indices separately for each clade associated with each haplotype. The program FSTAT v220.127.116.11 was used to calculate gene diversity (Hs) and allelic richness (Ar) (Franks et al. 2010).
GENEPOP v3.4 (Weir & Cockerham 1984) was used to test for linkage disequilibrium between all pairs of loci and to test for deviation from Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) at each locus for each population; this was done with Markov chain parameters of 10,000 dememorization steps, followed by 1,000 batches of 10,000 iterations per batch (Raymond & Rousset 1995) in combination with Fisher's exact tests. The BOTTLENECK software was used to test for deviation from mutation-drift equilibrium (Cornuet & Luikart 1996). To identify the bottleneck event for each population, we investigate the occurrence of significant heterozygosity excess (which is a signature of a bottleneck) within all of the populations within clades under 3 mutational models (TPM, two-phase model of mutation; IAM, infinite alleles model; and SMM, stepwise mutation model). The TPM model was performed with the default settings of 30% variation from the IAM model and 70% from the SMM model.
A regular linear regression of the relationship between expected heterozygosity (He) and geographical distance from the nearest likely source population (the region of introduction mentioned in historical reports) was tested using Sigmaplot 12.0. The Google Earth ruler tool (Anderson & Congdon 2013) was used to calculate the Euclidean distance.
Analysis of Genetic Structure and Gene Flow
Differentiation approach based on FST analysis was used. GENEPOP v3.4 (Raymond & Rousset 1995) was used to calculate Weir and Cockerham's estimator of the fixation index FST (Weir & Cockerham 1984). Isolation by distance (IBD) based on genetic differentiation and the logarithm of geographic distance was examined by using 10,000 permutations of the Mantel test implemented in IBDWS v3.15 ( http://www.ibdws.sdsu.edu) (Jensen et al. 2005; Hasselman et al. 2013). Distances between sampling locations were calculated using the Google Earth ruler tool (Anderson & Congdon 2013). Gene flow among regions was approximated as Nm (analogous to M = (1/FST -1)/2) (Slatkin 1993).
To evaluate the assignment of A. mali individuals to clusters, we also analyzed all of the populations and the 6 mixed populations using STRUCTURE software (Pritchard et al. 2000). For all populations analysis, we set K (number of clusters) from 1 to 16 with 6 iterations of this parameter set, using a burn-in of 20 000 followed by 50 000 iterations of Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC). For 6 mixed populations analysis, we set K (number of clusters) from 1 to 6. Other parameters were similar with aforementioned. The most optimal K was estimated by examining the standardized second-order change of ◃K (Evanno et al. 2005). Sigmaplot 12.0 was used to graphically display the results.
Microsatellite-Based Genetic Diversity
Among the 6 pure populations in the SD clade (i.e., populations that were 100% Hapl) (Zhang et al. 2014), the genetic diversity was highest in the QD population, which was the first population in that clade that was introduced, and was lowest in the ZT population (Table 1). Genetic diversity was not substantially lower and in some cases was higher in the CZ (Changzhi, Shanxi), YC (Yuncheng, Shanxi), WF (Weifang, Shandong), and YT (Yantai, Shandong) mixed populations of the SD clade than in the QD population (Table 1; Table S1).
Among the 4 pure populations in the LN clade (i.e., populations that were 100% Hap2) (Zhang et al. 2014), the genetic diversity was highest in the DL population, which was the first population in that clade that was introduced (Table 1). As was the case with mixed populations in the SD clade, genetic diversity was not substantially lower and in some cases was higher in the CZ (Changzhi, Shanxi), BD (Baoding, Hebei), WF(Weifang, Shandong), and YT (Yantai, Shandong) mixed populations of the LN clade (Table 1; Table S1). Geographic distance was not correlated with expected heterozygosity (He) for the SD clade (R2 = 0.3825, F = 4.9548, df = 1, P = 0.0567) or the LN clade (R2 = 0.0431, F = 0.3152, df = l,P = 0.5920) (Fig. 1).
Except for the YL population, all populations with small sample sizes significantly deviated from HWE. A strong inbreeding was evident (0.424 < Fis < 1.000), and the deviations were associated with a significant positive Fis value. Null alleles were not a major factor contributing to deviations from HWE because PCR amplifications were successful for 98.1% of each locus across all populations (Table S2). We could not use software to test for null alleles because the software assumes random mating. When tested for deviation from mutation-drift equilibrium in BOTTLENECK under the IAM, 9 of 20 populations had significant heterozygosity excess (Wilcoxon test P < 0.05) (Table S3). However, a significant heterozygosity excess was detected in only 4 populations under the TPM model and in only one population under the SMM model (Table S3).
Population Genetic Structure and Gene Flow When paired populations were considered, all of the 120 F ST values were significant (Table 2). Isolation by distance analysis revealed a significant positive correlation between genetic distance and the logarithm of geographical distance (Fig. 2).
Estimates of gene flow between paired populations (Table 2) revealed that QHD and BD had the highest gene flow (Nm = 39.183) and that gene flow was also relatively high (Nm > 10) for YC and CZ, BD and DL, QHD and DL, TA and HZ, QD and WF, and QD and YT (see population codes in Table 1). While ZT and YL had the lowest gene flow (Nm = 0.141), and both of these populations also had low gene flow with other populations.
According to STRUCTURE software, the genetic structure of all of the 16 populations in China was best described as consisting of 2 clusters (K = 2) (Fig. 3). The result demonstrated that the individuals within mitochondrial clades cannot be differentiated based on nuclear microsatellite loci.
Our study indicates that the nuclear genetic diversity among pure populations was highest in the initially introduced population of each clade, which was the QD population for the SD clade and the DL population for the LN clade; genetic diversity was much lower in the other pure populations (Table 1). The result suggests that the current distribution of A. mali in the introduced range is closely associated with the expansion from the 2 initially established populations, which acted as bridgehead populations, as has been shown for several invasive insects (Miller et al. 2005; Ciosi et al. 2008; Ascunce et al. 2011; Lombaert et al. 2010; Lombaert et al. 2011; Kajita et al. 2012; Yang et al. 2012). The result also confirms that the first two introduced populations, i.e., those in Qingdao, Shandong and Dalian, Liaoning, have served as the bridgeheads for the other populations in China as revealed by mitochondrial DNA markers (Zhang et al. 2014).
PAIRWISE F ST MATRIX (BELOW DIAGONAL) AND GENE FLOW (ABOVE DIAGONAL) OF 16 APHELINUS MALI POPULATIONS IN CHINA.
The initial founder effects may result in high genetic diversity near introduction points, but serial founder effects of other introduced populations may cause lower genetic diversity (Kajita et al. 2012). If the dispersal of A. mali is limited by distance, genetic diversity and geographical distances should be negatively correlated. However, the genetic diversity of A. mali was not correlated with geographical distance for either clade in China. That might be explained by anthropogenic influence on the spread of A. mali; the frequent transport of fruit seedlings may have facilitated the spread of the natural enemy of the woolly apple aphid. Another possibility is that the bottleneck effect during the subsequent introductions of A. mali was small or was mitigated by gene flow. Alien species normally experience founder or bottleneck effects, resulting in a loss of genetic diversity (Nei et al. 1975; Templeton 1980; Barton & Charlesworth 1984).
In our study, the reduction of genetic diversity within some populations might have been caused by bottlenecks (Table S3). However, most of the populations did not exhibit a heterozygosity excess (especially according to TPM or SMM models), which suggests that the bottleneck effect is a transient feature. High gene flow between populations may also obscure the genetic effects of a bottleneck (Table 2). For example, in the 4 mixed populations of the SD clade, the nuclear genetic diversity had not substantially decreased in YT and YC relative to that in QD and had even increased in WF and CZ (Fig. 1A). A similar phenomenon occurred in LN clade (Fig. 1B). Compared to the nuclear genetic diversity of the bridgehead population (DL) of the LN clade, the nuclear genetic diversity had not substantially decreased in YT and BD and had even increased in WF and CZ. In conclusion, bottleneck effects or gene flow may affect the correlation between genetic diversity and distance from the first established populations.
Hybridization or gene flow occurred between the 2 mitochondrial clades based on nuclear microsatellite loci (Fig. 3). The individuals within mitochondrial clades could not be differentiated based on nuclear microsatellite loci. A positive Fis index significantly different from zero (Table 1) indicates heterozygote deficiency and suggests inbreeding. This finding is consistent with the possibility of high gene flow between populations, which may obscure the genetic effects of a bottleneck. High gene flow between populations is not surprising, given the geographical proximity of the 2 release sites.
High gene flow can limit the genetic distance between nearby populations while low gene flow can increase the genetic distance between distant populations (Scott et al. 2005). Because of the high gene flow among plant species and locations, A. mali populations in Chile exhibit very low genetic differentiation (Lavandero et al. 2011). In the current study, however, FST analyses showed that A. mali populations in China have clearly undergone genetic differentiation in the expansion range. The positive correlation between genetic and geographic distance (Fig. 2) is associated with the low flight capacity of A. mali, which limits its natural dispersal ability. With low or moderate migration, genetic differentiation between regions and a significant isolationby-distance effect (Scott et al. 2005) occurred. Additionally, these results suggest a tendency for A. mali immigration from nearby rather than from distant populations in spite of accidental human transportation, a tendency that is consistent with the data concerning gene flow between populations (Table 2).
Invasive species have become serious problems in many regions because of their widespread and large effects on ecosystems, economies, and societies (Lockwood et al. 2007). Unraveling the dispersal pattern of invasive species is crucial for predicting and preventing additional invasions (Lockwood et al. 2007; Wilson et al. 2009). The study of the dispersal pattern of the invasive species is difficult (Chu et al. 2013), however, because the initial establishment of the invasive species can rarely be detected; the invasive species are typically not detected until a substantial time has passed after the initial introduction. Information about the further spread of “invasive” species can be gained, however, by the study of intentionally introduced biological control agents. Such agents provide an opportunity to test the effects of bridgehead populations and further spread because the timing, duration, and intensity of a demographic bottleneck are often well documented (Sakai et al. 2001; Hufbauer & Roderick 2005; Marsico et al. 2009; Franks et al. 2010).
To our knowledge, this is the first study to use the nuclear microsatellite loci to determine the hybridization and gene flow within 2 clades of A. mali in China. The genetic admixture of populations arising from different bridgeheads may help the biological control agent to adapt to the conditions in the introduced regions. The results obtained with an introduced biological control agent suggest that invasion by a species with limited dispersal ability may be facilitated by the establishment of multiple bridgehead populations.
Supplementary material for this article in Florida Entomologist 97(2) (June, 2014) is online at http://purl.fcla.edu/fcla/entomologist/browse. This material includes the following 3 tables of additional supporting information:
Table S1. Population-genetics summary statistics BASED ON ASSIGNMENT OF EIGHT MICROSATELLITE LOCI TO DIFFERENT CLADES IN MIXED POPULATIONS OF APHELINUS MALI IN CHINA.
Table S2. Allele sizes at eight microsatellite loci SCREENED FOR APHELINUS MALI
Table S3. P values for within-population tests for HETEROZYGOSITY EXCESS IN 16 APHELINUS MALI POPULATIONS IN CHINA.
Hong-Xu Zhou and Rui-Ming Zhang contributed equally to this work. We are grateful to Dr. Gabor Lovei (Department of Agroecology, Aarhus University) and Blas Lavandero (Instituto de Biología Vegetal y Biotecnología, Laboratorio de Interacciones Insecto-Planta, Universidad de Talca, Chile) for his detailed comments on this manuscript. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation (31371994), the National Key Basic Research Development Plan Project (2013CB127600), the Science and Technology Development Planning Program of Qingdao (13-1-3-108-nsh), the Special Fund for Agro-scientific Research in the Public Interest (201103026-5-2), and the Taishan Mountain Scholar Constructive Engineering Foundation of Shandong, China.