We estimated hooking and landing success and relative hooking mortality for stream-dwelling trout caught with baited circle and J hooks, J hook dry flies, and treble hook spinners (all hooks barbed). Trout were caught, individually marked, and released for 69 days. Deep-hooking rate was higher for trout captured with baited J hooks (21%) than for spinners (5%), baited circle hooks (4%), and dry flies (1%). Relative mortality rate was higher for trout captured with baited J hooks (25%) and spinners (29%) than for trout captured with baited circle hooks (7%) and dry flies (4%). Deep-hooking was two and six times higher for baited J hooks than baited circle hooks for fish caught actively and passively , respectively. For baited circle hooks, deep-hooking was over three times greater when using an active fishing method (i.e., an active hookset) compared to passive fishing method (no hookset), which conflicts with manufacturer&s recommendations on how circle hooks should be fished. Hooking success (ratio of hook-ups to number of fish strikes) was about one-third lower for baited circle hooks fished both passively and actively compared to other hook types and fishing methods, except for passively-fished baited J hooks. Once hooked, landing success (ratio of fish landed to number of hook-ups) was relatively high for all hook types and fishing methods (range 68–87%). Our results suggest that when bait fishing for trout in streams, circle hook use may reduce deep-hooking and hooking mortality (but also catch rate) regardless of whether anglers fish passively or actively.