Translator Disclaimer
1 July 2011 Phylogeny and Taxonomy of Mentzelia Section Bartonia (Loasaceae)
John J. Schenk, Larry Hufford
Author Affiliations +

Taxonomic problems in Mentzelia section Bartonia (Loasaceae) are addressed using phylogeny reconstructions based on nuclear ribosomal DNA sequences from the ITS and ETS regions. Our results indicate sect. Bartonia is monophyletic and consists of two well-supported, species-rich clades. One of these two deepest clades consists of the Great Plains M. decapetala and a group of species centered in the North American intermountain region that have been described as subshrubby; whereas, the second deepest clade is more widespread and includes taxa from the Chihuahuan and Sonoran deserts as well as the Great Plains, Rocky Mountains, and intermountain region. Hypothesis tests applying the Shimodaira-Hasegawa (SH) test and Bayes factors (BF) rejected unequivocally the monophyly of (1) the ‘subshrubby’ group, suggesting multiple origins of the ‘subshrubby’ form; (2) M. multicaulis s. l., which consists of disparate clades we propose as separate species; and (3) M. multiflora s. l., which was recovered as highly polyphyletic. Hypothesis tests were equivocal, however, in regard to the monophyly of (1) M. marginata, M. paradoxensis, and M. cronquistii; (2) M. oreophila s. l.; and (3) M. pumila s. l. We suggest following narrow taxonomic approaches to the circumscriptions of M. multicaulis, M. multiflora, and M. pumila and advocate further studies of M. oreophila and the complex including of M. marginata, M. paradoxensis, and M. cronquistii. Our results provide the most comprehensive phylogenetic hypothesis of sect. Bartonia to date, however, more variable markers will be needed to resolve a well supported phylogeny.

© Copyright 2011 by the American Society of Plant Taxonomists
John J. Schenk and Larry Hufford "Phylogeny and Taxonomy of Mentzelia Section Bartonia (Loasaceae)," Systematic Botany 36(3), 711-720, (1 July 2011).
Published: 1 July 2011

Bayes factors
hypothesis test
plant systematics
polyphyletic species
Shimodaira-Hasegawa test
Get copyright permission
Back to Top