Open Access
How to translate text using browser tools
1 October 2000 Birding in the American West: A Handbook
W. Marvin Davis
Author Affiliations +

Birding in the American West: A Handbook.—Kevin J. Zimmer. 2000. Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York. x + 402 FPAGE, 111 text figures. ISBN 0-8014-3257-X. Cloth, $49.95. ISBN 0-8014-8328-X. Paper, $25.00.—This indeed is a handbook in name and size, but it is well suited as a “handy book” for many reasons. The FPAGE are packed with useful information for North American birders of just about any orientation or level of accomplishment except, perhaps, for the few so advanced as to be qualified to research and write such a formidable work themselves. Although definitely focused on the West, this volume would be of value even to those easterners who may never intend (heaven forbid!) to visit the West in pursuit of its birdlife. The author's definition of “West” includes the 18 continental states west of the line running from the eastern border of North Dakota and intervening states to Texas. However, with respect to scope of content, Zimmer departs from the conventional.

Approximately one-fourth of the book (Chapter 5) comprises what one would expect from the title, namely, help with locating 268 selected “western specialty” bird species. The vast 18-state western area encompasses the great majority of all avian species to be found in the entire United States, and the region provides a great range of excellent opportunities for birding. This volume has the merit of making more data on localities for the “western specialties” readily accessible than can be gleaned from range maps in field guides. Obviously, less detail is included than in the many western state or local bird-finding guides. Any novice eastern birder planning a western expedition could use this chapter profitably to avoid consulting numerous bird-finding guides, but more widely read birders might see the less-detailed information in Zimmer's volume extraneous.

The assembling of bird-finding locality data across 18 states was a daunting task that drew upon a great many published sources as well as the author's personal experiences. For such a compilation to be error-free would be most remarkable and unexpected, but my personal familiarity with an area calls forth the mention of at least one discrepancy. The Wichita Mountains of southwestern Oklahoma do not extend beyond Comanche County into Caddo, Canadian, and Blaine counties north of the Wichitas, as cited on page 352; what all these areas have in common is habitat suitable for the endangered Black-capped Vireo (Vireo atricapillus).

Not so expected is that 50% (Chapter 4) of the handbook is devoted to aids for correctly making many of the more difficult identifications (e.g. the three larger Sterna; Myiarchus and Empidonax flycatchers; Aphelocoma jays; the wing-barred vireos; Bendires's Thrasher [Toxostoma bendirei] versus Curve-billed Thrasher [T. curvirostre]). Certainly, these aids would be a great benefit on a western trip. Moreover, because many of the problems within pairs or groups of species also occur upon occasion in the American East, Chapter 4 has considerable value wherever one pursues birds in the United States or Canada. These 200 FPAGE can be seen as taking the user beyond the field guides, and even a step beyond what was provided in Kenn Kaufman's 1990 Guide to Advanced Birding, to which Zimmer contributed the chapter on Thayer's Gull (Larus thayeri). This chapter benefits from excellent line drawings by Shawneen Finnegan, Dale Zimmerman, and Mimi Hoppe Wolf that compare two or more species. The black-and-white photos, mostly by the widely traveled author (a leader of far-ranging bird tours) or by Barry Zimmer, further aid the aspiring advanced birder. The valuable bibliography of 206 citations extends from 1951 to 1999, but with only a few after 1996. Most of the citations are identification articles in journals such as Birding, American Birds, Western Birds, and even a few from British Birds. Others are mainly local, state, and regional bird-finding guides, going back to O. S. Pettingill's (1951, 1981) pioneering eastern and western guides, and the various identification field guides.

Perhaps most unexpected from the title is that nearly 20% of the book, in the first three chapters, consists of fundamental material describing how to be a good birder. In some respects, this seems to be a three-chapter précis of a semester nonmajor course in introductory ornithology. Chapter 1, “Techniques of Finding Birds,” offers a fundamental, but by no means simplistic, introduction to the birding pursuit. It deals with the role that habitats, key plants, elevation, life zones, nest-site availability, time of day, season, and migration may play in birding in a succinct but informative way, providing a sound foundation for the novice to build upon. This chapter also deals with published and electronic sources of information (e.g. rare bird alerts accessible via telephone with numbers listed for the West, or the Internet) for locating rare species. Zimmer even provides an introduction to pelagic birding, describes methods of calling in birds by audio aids, and then goes very appropriately into ethics for birder field behavior. The latter is a topic with increasing significance as numbers of birders continue to swell.

Chapter 2, “Techniques of Identifying Birds,” continues where concise field identification guides stop. This chapter teaches the approaches to correctly identifying most of the birds one encounters, and Chapter 4 deals with the remaining species. Chapter 2 also includes a thumbnail sketch of all the avian families encountered in the West. It closes with a desirable section on “Psychological Influences,” cautioning the birder against allowing enthusiasm to overwhelm good judgement in “identifying” rare species when one's basis for identification may be inadequate, often leading to an “unsanitary” report and a pain for the bird records committee to deal with.

The third and shortest chapter, “Keeping Field Notes,” is a well-chosen segue away from decrying careless over-enthusiasm in bird identification toward exhorting birders to cultivate the habit of making excellent field notes, an essential skill for producing desirable “sanitary” identifications. These first three chapters could serve to transform a person with a very casual approach to birding into a well-disciplined candidate for “advanced birder.”

As many students of North American birding browse this book, they will enjoy being reminded of or finding anew the numerous useful and interesting items of information on birding places and bird species of the American West. It is tempting to suggest that it is a “goldmine” deserving of exploration, discovery and the extraction of delightful “nuggets.” It is well worth the cost for any active birder to add it to his or her library. It should be favorably recommended for purchase by any library that covers North American birds.

Literature Cited


K. Kaufman 1990. A field guide to advanced birding. Houghton-Mifflin, Boston. Google Scholar


O. S. Pettingill 1951. A guide to bird finding east of the Mississippi. Oxford University Press, New York. Google Scholar


O. S. Pettingill 1981. Guide to bird finding west of the Mississippi. Oxford University Press, New York. Google Scholar


W. Marvin Davis "Birding in the American West: A Handbook," The Auk 117(4), 1090-1092, (1 October 2000).[1090:BITAWA]2.0.CO;2
Published: 1 October 2000
Back to Top