Allium oreohellenicum Tzanoud., Tsakiri & Raus (Amaryllidaceae), endemic of the Greek mountains, is described and illustrated as a species new to science. Information regarding its cytology, geographical distribution and taxonomic relationships is also provided. Material belonging to A. oreohellenicum was formerly known/classified as A. achaium Boiss & Orph., a taxon described in 1882 based on a gathering by Orphanides from Mt Klokos (N Peloponnisos, Greece). A detailed study of the Orphanides gathering concerned revealed that it essentially belongs to A. frigidum Boiss. & Heldr., a taxon described 28 years earlier, and so the need for a new name.
Citation: Tzanoudakis D., Tsakiri M. & Raus Th. 2019: What is Allium achaium Boiss. & Orph.? Disentangling the taxonomy of a Greek mountain species. – Willdenowia 49: 231–239. doi: https://doi.org/10.3372/wi.49.49211
Version of record first published online on 20 August 2019 ahead of inclusion in August 2019 issue.
Allium L. (Amaryllidaceae) is one of the most species-rich genera of the Greek flora. Presently it is known to be represented in the country by 103 species with more than 50 % of them (54) endemics. Considering that continental Greece including some of the larger islands is characterized by dozens of mountain massifs approaching or exceeding 2000 m in altitude, it is worth noting that among the Greek Allium endemics only three are considered as “mountain species”, i.e. adapted to and exclusively occurring in high-altitude habitats (>1600 m). These species are currently named A. achaium Boiss. & Orph., A. frigidum Boiss. & Heldr. and A. parnassicum (Boiss.) Halácsy (Strid & Tan 1991; Dimopoulos & al. 2013). They have some morphological characters in common, viz. an infundibular-campanulate to infundibular perianth, the perianth segments at least 6 mm long, the stamens included in the perianth, and the ovary much longer than wide.
Allium frigidum Boiss. & Heldr. was first published in Boissier (1854: 34) based on a gathering by Heldre-ich from Mt Taygetos (S Peloponnisos). Allium achaium Boiss. & Orph. was described 28 years later (Boissier 1882: 259) based on a gathering by Orphanides from Mt Klokos (NW Peloponnisos), distributed to Boissier (G, G-BOISS) and several other herbaria under Orphanides, Fl. Gr. Exsicc. no. 427 (“In monte Clocos Achaia et prope Vostitza sito loco Pente Vryses dicto 4000 ped., 9/21. Jul. 1855”). Together with A. achaium, Boissier described slightly deviating plants from Mt Parnassos (Sterea Ellas) as A. achaium var. parnassicum Boiss. (Boissier 1882: 259). Halácsy (1904: 255) raised this variety to species rank (A. parnassicum (Boiss.) Halácsy), at the same time considering A. achaium Boiss. & Orph. to be a synonym of A. frigidum, stating: “Inter A. frigidum et A. achaium differentiam videre nequeo” and “A. achaium quo meo sensu ab A. frigido non diversum” (Halácsy 1904: 251, 255). Halácsy's concept of the A. achaium group was adopted by Hayek (1932: 47), Zahariadi (1975a, 1975b), Stearn (1978, 1980, 1981) and Kollmann (1984: 135). On the contrary, A. achaium has been subsequently reappraised as a distinct species of the Greek flora by Andersson (1991: 709), with the Orphanides gathering from Mt Klokos in G-BOISS as the holotype of the species and its total distribution range indicated from Peloponnisos to the mountains of Sterea Ellas and Southern and Northern Pindos (Thessalia/Ipiros).
Twenty years later, Bogdanović & al. (2011) completely changed the taxonomic treatment of Allium achaium. Indeed they continued to quote the voucher of Orphanides, Fl. Gr. Exsicc. no. 427 (G-BOISS) as the holotype of A. achaium, but confusingly described and illustrated under this designation an Allium from Mt Klokos characterized by morphological characters that do not at all match either the specimens of the Orphanides gathering, mentioned above, or any other specimen belonging to the species group of A. achaium sensu Andersson (1991) and previous botanists, A. frigidum and A. parnassicum (Fig. 1). In fact, the characters given by Bogdanović & al. (2011), viz. exserted stamens, cup-shaped perianth and globose ovary, characterize the A. flavum/A. stamineum group, which is quite different from those groups in which A. achaium, A. frigidum and A. parnassicum belong (with the stamens included in an infundibular-campanulate to infundibular perianth and the ovary much longer than wide; Fig. 1 & 2). The present paper aims at disentangling these contradicting taxonomic points of view.
Material and methods
Mt Klokos, the locus classicus of Allium achaium Boiss. & Orph., had been visited and explored by the first author, accompanied by varying staff of the Botanical Institute of Patras, several times from 2013 to 2017 in the framework of monitoring regional “Natura 2000” sites, and all Allium taxa occurring in the area have been completely registered. In parallel, herbarium specimens of A. achaium sensu Andersson (1991), A. frigidum and A. parnassicum from all mountains of Peloponnisos, Sterea Ellas and the Pindos range, which are available in the Botanical Museum of the University of Patras (UPA), have been comparatively studied, among them an iso-type sheet of the original gathering by Orphanides from Mt Klokos (Orphanides, Fl. Gr. Exsicc. no. 427), on which the description of A. achaium was based (Fig. 5). In addition, the type material of the three species A. achaium, A. frigidum and A. parnassicum deposited in the Geneva herbarium (G, G-BOISS) was investigated. Herbarium specimens of these three species examined by Andersson (1991) and deposited in the herbarium of Lund (LD) were also examined. No relevant historical exsiccata could be traced in the herbarium of Berlin (B), very likely destroyed there in 1943.
Results and Discussion
Mt Klokos (1774 m) is situated SW of the city of Egion (previously Vostitsa) and NNW of the much higher mountain massifs of Chelmos (2355 m) and Erimanthos (2224 m) in northern Peloponnisos. Based on the information given by local people, the locality “Pente Vryses” (i.e. five springs), which is given on the label of Orphanides, Fl. Gr. Exsicc. no. 427, is located a few kilo-metres SW of Pteri, a village on the NE-facing slope of the mountain at an altitude of c. 1300 m. The altitude given by Orphanides for this locality is almost the same (4000 ft). In the framework of our floristic exploration, we visited the slopes above the locality “Pente Vryses” as well as the opposite, SSE-facing slopes from an altitude of 1400 m up to the summit area. During our field work, three Allium species were found in the area:
(1) The first, and most common one, was a representative of Allium sect. Codonoprasum (Rchb.) Endl. characterized by spathe valves longer than pedicels, the perianth 4–5 mm long with evidently exserted stamens and a globose, more or less stipitate ovary (Fig. 1D & 2D). It was found on the slopes just above the locality “Pente Vryses” as well as on the opposite-facing slopes and in the summit area. Without any doubt this is the plant that Bogdanović & al. (2011) described and considered as the “true A. achaium”, although none of the plants of the Orphanides gathering from Mt Klokos (G!, UPA!) has any of the characters provided by Bogdanović & al. (2011). However, plants with the mentioned characters do occur in the mountains of Greece, where they are more or less common and widespread; they represent A. flavum subsp. tauricum (Besser ex Rchb.) K. Richt.
(2) The second taxon met with on Mt Klokos was an Allium characterized by hairy sheaths and leaves, very long spathe valves and a pinkish brown perianth with included stamens. Because of these characters it belongs to A. rhodopeum Velen. subsp. rhodopeum, a taxon also known to occur at moderate altitudes on other mountains next to Mt Klokos in N Peloponnisos.
(3) The third representative of the genus on Mt Klokos was an Allium characterized by a pendulous inflorescence, spathe valves shorter than pedicels, white-pinkish to brownish perianth, included stamens and an ovoid to ellipsoid ovary. Only a few individuals were found, confined to the summit area. When comparing this plant with material of A. frigidum from other mountains of Peloponnisos as well as with the plants of the Orphanides gathering from Mt Klokos (G!, UPA!) designated as the type material of A. achaium, we found no differences. Hence Halácsy (1904) was completely correct in pointing out that there is no difference between these two taxa (“inter A. frigidum et A. achaium differentiam videre nequeo”). They are conspecific, and the name A. frigidum has priority over A. achaium, hence the latter is correctly treated as a synonym of the former by Halácsy (1904), Hayek (1932–1933), Zahariadi (1975a, 1975b), Stearn (1978, 1980, 1981) and Kollmann (1984).
There is no doubt that in high-altitude habitats of the mountains of N Peloponnisos one more taxon of the Allium paniculatum group is present, sometimes growing side by side with A. frigidum. It is characterized by having outer bulb tunics often longitudinally splitting into parallel fibres, inflorescence erect (versus pendulous in A. frigidum), spathe valves longer than the pedicels, perianth segments pinkish white in the living state, to 6(–6.5) mm long, stamens with white-yellowish anthers included in the perianth, and ovary much longer than wide, narrowed at the base and truncate at the apex (Fig. 1A, 2A & 4). Plants with a similar morphology have also been collected in the high mountains of Sterea Ellas and in the Pindos range of NW Greece (Thessalia/ Ipiros) and were treated by Tzanoudakis & Vosa (1988) under the misnomer “A. parnassicum”. These plants were erroneously classified by Andersson (1991) as A. achaium. We agree with Andersson, who recognized a third Allium species in the mountains of C and NW continental Greece in addition to A. frigidum and A. parnassicum. However, Andersson misapplied the name A. achaium and its type, chosen by him, to this third species, whereas in fact they belong taxonomically to A. frigidum. This third species therefore needs a new name, a new description and a new type, which are provided here.
Holotype: Greece, Peloponnisos, Achaia, Mt Chelmos, near Pouliou Vrisi, 39°59′26″N, 22°11′13″E, c. 2020 m, grassland and rocky places, 11 Aug 2018, Tzanoudakis 14682 (UPA [Fig. 4]).
Diagnosis — Species ad sectionem Codonoprasum Allii generis pertinens, ab Allio parnassico simili non modo caule robustiore, floribus compluribus, periantho roseo-albo ad 6(–6.5) mm tantum longo antherisque albofla-vidis, sed etiam chromosomatum numero plerumque triploideo (2n = 3x = 24) satis diversa.
Allium oreohellenicum is a species of the Greek mountain flora, a member of the A. paniculatum group in A. sect. Codonoprasum. It is similar to A. parnassicum, from which it chiefly differs by its more robust stem (slender in A. parnassicum), inflorescence with more flowers, perianth segments pinkish white, smaller, to 6(–6.5) mm long (versus purplish to brownish purple and to 7.5 mm long in A. parnassicum), anthers white-yellowish (versus purple in A. parnassicum) and mainly triploid chromosome number (2n = 3x = 24), rarely diploid (2n = 16) (versus only diploid in A. parnassicum).
Description — Bulb ovoid, 1–1.3(–1.8) cm in diam.; outer tunics brown to blackish brown, coriaceous, often longitudinally splitting into parallel fibres; inner tunics brownish to whitish brown, membranous. Bulblets 1 or 2, oblong-ovoid, 3–4 × 1–1.5 mm, apex acu-minate, sometimes stalked on lower part of stem. Stem erect, (7–)10–20(–30) cm long, glabrous, covered by leaf sheaths for c. ½ of its length. Leaves 2 or 3(or 4), filiform, usually shorter than stem, glabrous, withered at flowering time. Spathes 2, opposite, unequal, 5- or 6-nerved, lanceo-late at base and gradually attenuate into an appendage at apex, longer one 3–5(–8) cm long, shorter one 2–3(–4) cm long. Inflorescence usually lax with (7–)10–20(–35) flowers, marginal ones pendulous, central ones erect. Pedicels unequal, 1–1.5(–2.5) cm long. Perianth campanulate to funnel-shaped; perianth segments pinkish white in living state, sometimes becoming greenish brown when dry, elliptic to obovate, 5–6(–6.5) × 1–1.5(–2) mm. Stamens included; filaments ± similar, white, connate below into an annulus c. 1 mm long; anthers white-yellowish. Ovary cylindric to obovoid, longer than wide, c. 3 × 1.5–1.8 mm, narrowed at base, truncate and papillose at apex. Style white, 2–3 mm long.
Karyology — Material of Allium oreohellenicum from the mountains of Peloponnisos and Sterea Ellas was investigated cytologically by Tzanoudakis & Vosa (1988, under “A. parnassicum”). The triploid chromosome number 2n = 3x = 24 was reported from all examined populations, but the diploid chromosome number, 2n = 2x = 16, was additionally found in some individuals from Mts Iti and Velouchi in Sterea Ellas. The chromosome morphology and karyograms from the populations concerned were given by Tzanoudakis (1992: fig. 3 & 6), who pointed out that in both diploid and triploid plants the haploid complement consists mainly of metacentric and submetacen-tric chromosomes. The SAT-chromosomes observed (mA, SmA) belong to the “paniculatum” type sensu Tzanoudakis (1983). In the present study, plants from the type gathering were also cytologically investigated and likewise turned out to be triploid (2n = 3x = 24, Fig. 3).
Distribution — The total range of Allium oreohellenicum, as presently known (Fig. 6), covers C and NW continental Greece from N Pindos (Mt Smolikas, see Andersson 1991: 709, under “A. achaium”) to Sterea Ellas (Mt Vardousia), extending to N Peloponnisos (Mts Chelmos, Erimanthos, Killini and Panachaiko) where it co-occurs with A. frigidum.
Ecology — Allium oreohellenicum grows preferentially at 1800–2400 m in high-mountain meadows and rocky places, flowering from mid-July to August, depending on altitude and exposition. In the type locality, it is accompanied by several endemic and critical taxa such as Allium frigidum Boiss. & Heldr., A. phthioticum Boiss. & Heldr., Campanula aizoides Zaffran ex Greuter, Cerastium candidissimum Correns, Festuca jeanpertii (St.-Yves) Markgr., Minuartia juniperina (L.) Maire & Petitm., Senecio rupestris Waldst. & Kit., Solenanthus stamineus (Desf.) Wettst. and Verbascum epixanthinum Boiss. & Heldr.
Etymology — The specific epithet is a compound of oreo (mountain) and hellenicum (Greek), reflecting the ecological and chorological traits of the species, which is confined to high-mountain habitats of continental Greece. The taxon was hitherto concealed by misapplication of the name Allium achaium (Andersson 1991) or by mis-identification of A. flavum subsp. tauricum (Bogdanović & al. 2011).
Additional specimens examined — NORTHERN PINDOS: Ioannina: Mt Timfi, near Drakolimni, 39°58.5259′N, 20°46.54′E, alt. 1880 m, 6 Aug 2017, Kofinas (UPA). — SOUTHERN PINDOS: Ioannina: Mt Katarachias, 5.5 km ENE of Kalarites, alt. c. 2050 m, 25 Aug 1974, Aldén 5339 (LD); Mts Athamanika, Kakarditsa, 39°32.0279′N, 21°11.3169′E, alt. 1940 m, 5 Aug 2017, Kofinas (UPA); Trikala: Mt Kotziakas, 6 km E of Pertoulion, alt. 1750–1850 m, 7 Aug 1974, Aldén 4815 (LD). — STEREA ELLAS: Evritania: Mt Velouchi, ad locum Seitan dictum, 38°56′N, 21°48′E, alt. c. 1800 m, 17 Aug 1981, Tzanoudakis 6725 (UPA); ibid., in regione cacuminis, 38°57′N, 21°50′E, alt. c. 2100 m, 17 Aug 1981, Tzanoudakis 6722 (UPA); ibid., 6 km ENE of Karpenision, alt. 1750–1850 m, 24 Jul 1970, Gustavsson 364 (LD); Fokida: Mt Vardousia, 7 km W of Athanasios Diakos, alt. c. 1975 m, 9 Aug 1973, Gustavsson 3595 (LD); ibid., prope refugium EOS, 13 Aug 1980, Tzanoudakis & Georgiadis 6604 (UPA); ibid., in cacumine Korakas, 38°41′N, 22°08′E, alt. c. 2400 m, 13 Aug 1980 Tzanoudakis & Georgiadis 6607 (UPA); ibid., 4 km W of Athanasios Diakos, alt 1750 m, 11 Aug 1973, Gustavsson 3699 (LD); ibid., 5 km NNE of Dafnos, alt. c. 2000 m, Gustavsson (cultivated and dried 22 Jul 1974, LD); Fthiotida: Mt Iti, inter Pavliani et Katavothra, alt. 1500–1600 m, in sylvaticis, 3 Aug 1987, Tzanoudakis s.n. (UPA); ibid., inter Katavothra et Vrisi Kalogerou, 38°49′N, 22°16′E, alt. c. 1800 m, in pratis, 13 Aug 1980, Tzanoudakis 6603 (UPA); ibid., in regione cacuminis, c. 2000 m, 12 Aug 1980, Tzanoudakis & Georgiadis 6614 (UPA); ibid., near refugium EOS, alt. c. 1850 m, 12 Aug 1980, Tzanoudakis & Georgiadis 6606 (UPA); ibid., 5 km E of Neochorion, alt. 1900–2000 m, 27 Aug 1973, Gustavsson 4164 (LD); ibid., 7 km SSE of Ipati, alt. 1820–1850 m, 25 Jul 1972, Gustavsson 1926 (LD). — PELOPONNISOS: Achaia: Mt Chelmos, Gaidou-rorachi, above Souvardiotoki Kria Vrisi, alt. c. 1500 m, 20 Jul 2003, Tzanoudakis X653 (UPA); ibid., near refugium EOS, 37°59.414′N, 22°11.386′E, alt. 2080 m, 18 Jul 2012, Tzanoudakis & al. X726 (UPA); ibid., forest road from Pouliou Vrisi to Aristarchos, 37°58.939′N, 22°11.494′E, alt. 2020 m, 18 Jul 2012, Tzanoudakis & al. X759 (UPA); ibid., 37°59.391′N, 22°11.298′E, alt. 2100 m, 22 Aug 2012, Tzanoudakis X787 (UPA); Mt Erimanthos, ad locum Mesa Gouvia dictum, 37°57′N, 21°47′E, alt. c. 1700 m, 20 Jun 1981, Tzanoudakis 6979 (UPA); ibid., ad cacu-men Neraidovouni, 38°01′N, 21°50′E, alt. c. 1700 m, 17 Jul 1973, Tzanoudakis 318b (UPA); Mt Panachaiko, supra pagum Balas, inter Kokkinovrisi et Prassoudi, prope Vrisi Despoti, alt. c. 1700 m, Tzanoudakis 5945 (UPA); ibid., 38°12′35.8″N, 21°51′32.7″E, alt. 1670 m, Kokkoris 2122 (UPA); Korinthia: Mt Ziria (Killini), pathway from refuge EOS (B) to summit, 37°57′N, 22°25′E, alt. 1650–1950 m, Dimopoulos 2769 (UPA).
Photographs and field observations — Peloponnisos: Achaia: Mt Panachaiko, mountain plateau of Prassoudi, alt. c. 1800 m, grassland, 11 Aug 2015, Tzanoudakis obs. & photos; Korinthia: Mt Ziria (Killini), 37.55°N, 22.25°E, alt. 1750 m, 12 Aug 2010, Polymenakos obs. & photos; ibid., 37.55°N, 22.24°E, alt. 1950 m, 7 Aug 2009, Kit Tan & al. obs.; ibid., 37.55°N, 22.28°E, alt. 1946 m, Zarkos obs.; ibid., alt. 1500 m, dry meadow with rocky limestone outcrops, 37.57°N, 22.25°E, 27 Jul 2013, Kit Tan, Vold & Zarkos obs.
Financial support of the field work by the Greek Ministry of the Environment and the Management Body of the “Chelmos-Vouraikos National Park” is gratefully acknowledged. We also thank the authorities and staff of the herbaria in Geneva (G) and Lund (LD) for sending specimens for comparative studies. We also thank Dr Kit Tan and Mr Ioannis Kofinas for photographs and information regarding the presence of the new species in Mt Ziria and the Pindos range, as well as Dr Panayotis Trigas for the photograph of Allium parnassicum. František Krahulec (Průhonice) and Panayotis Trigas (Athens) are thanked for their helpful comments on earlier versions of this paper.