Two new species of the genus Spinosatibiapalpus Gabriel & Sherwood, 2020 are described: S. paula sp. nov. from the Colombian Caribbean coast and S. neisi sp. nov. from central Colombia. Both species are proposed based on the morphology of the palpal bulb, tibial apophysis and spermathecae. Taxonomic keys for all known species of the genus and a distribution map for Colombian species are provided.