Hyla chrysoscelis (Cope's Gray Treefrog) and H. versicolor (Gray Treefrog) are common and important species in woodland ecosystems throughout Appalachia, including southeastern Ohio. While the monitoring of treefrogs is comparatively easy in their aquatic breeding habitat, accurately measuring relative abundance in their terrestrial dwelling is more difficult, and biologists must balance search effort with data quality and effectiveness. In this study, we used PVC pipe refugia of differing colors (gray and white) to monitor the treefrog population in a mixed deciduous forest, conducting 30 surveys (5 per year, spanning April–October) over a 6-year period (2018–2023). Treefrog abundances were largest in the first (April) and last (October) yearly surveys, suggesting that early and late-season surveys are sufficient for accurately assessing population trends and dynamics. We also detected a strong preference among treefrogs to utilize west-facing refugia stations, and a slight preference for white PVC refugia. In addition, we observed many non-target species in PVC pipe refugia, which may deter usage by treefrogs as they never co-occurred with other species.