Open Access
Translator Disclaimer
1 October 2009 Migration Patterns of Adult and Juvenile Lesser Black-Backed Gulls Larus fuscus from Northern Norway
Morten Helberg, Geir H. Systad, Ingve Birkeland, Nils H. Lorentzen, Jan O. Bustnes
Author Affiliations +
Abstract

To explore migration patterns of Lesser Black-backed Gulls Larus fuscus breeding in northern Norway, this study presents resightings of 16 adult and 83 juvenile birds marked in this region. Adults of the endangered nominate sub-species L. f. fuscus had a low probability of being observed (only 3.5% of marked birds were observed), probably because the adults winter in areas with few observers, such as eastern and central Africa. In contrast, birds of the greyish-mantled subspecies L. f. intermedius or L. f. graellsii had a high probability of being observed (45.5%). Adults of intermedius/graellsii had a western migration route and wintered mainly in western Europe and northwest Africa, Adults exhibited a high site fidelity to wintering areas. Birds marked as juveniles had two different migration routes. (1) 30% of the observed birds crossed the Scandinavian Peninsula to Finland and the Baltic countries, and then migrated to the eastern Mediterranean (Israel and Egypt) down to eastern and central Africa (Kenya and Cameroon). (2) The other 70% followed the European coast and overwintered in UK, the Iberian Peninsula, Morocco, Mauritania and Senegal. There were no indications that juvenile migration patterns differed among subspecies as juveniles from mixed and pure fuscus colonies exhibited similar patterns. The apparent differences in migration patterns between adult and juvenile fuscus may be a result of juvenile exploratory migration.

INTRODUCTION

In contrast to most other gull populations in northern Europe, the Lesser Black-backed Gull Larus fuscus is a long-distance migrant that may winter as far south as central Africa (Cramp & Simmons 1983, Kilpi & Saurola 1984, Bakken et al. 2003, Bonlokke et al. 2006). Traditionally, Norway has been home to two subspecies of the Lesser Black-backed Gull; the black-mantled nominate L. f. fuscus in mid and northern Norway and the greyish-mantled L. f. intermedius in the south (Cramp & Simmons 1983). L. f. fuscus populations have declined during the last decades and the subspecies is now endangered all over its distribution range in the Baltic Sea and northern Norway (Bevanger & Thingstad 1990, Strann & Vader 1992, Hario et al. 1998, 2004). In contrast, the Norwegian intermedius population increased steeply during the 1980s and early 1990s (Lorentsen 2007), and since the late 1980s greyish-mantled Lesser Black-backed Gulls with a L. f. intermedius appearance have been found in colonies in northern Norway which were previously occupied solely by the nominate fuscus (Strann & Vader 1992, Bustnes et al. 2006). It is not known whether these new birds originate from expanding intermedius colonies in southern Norway, or from colonies of a third subspecies, L. f. graellsii, which has increased in the North Sea area and in Ireland (Creme et al. 1997, Garthe et al. 1999), as these two subspecies are difficult to distinguish.

A large number of ring recoveries of Norwegian intermedius have consistently shown that they predominantly winter around the Iberian Peninsula, in the western Mediterranean, and down to Morocco and Mauritania (Bakken et al. 2003). The migration pattern and wintering areas of the Norwegian fuscus is, however, virtually unknown with only two recoveries from the Black Sea area being published. Based on these recoveries, it has been assumed that the Norwegian fuscus has a southeast migration (Bakken et al. 2003) in line with the Finnish and Danish fuscus populations for which a large number of recoveries have documented an eastern flyway through the Black Sea area and then south through the eastern Mediterranean, down the Rift Valley to freshwater systems in Ethiopia, Uganda and Kenya (Cramp & Simmons 1983, Kilpi & Saurola 1984, Kube et al. 2000, Hario et al. 2004, Bønløkke et al. 2006).

The aim of this study was to unravel the migration pattern of adult and juvenile Lesser Black-backed Gulls from northern Norway, and also to document whether L. f. fuscus and greyish-mantled birds show different migrations. To achieve these aims, a ringing program has been carried out in 12 colonies along the coast of northern Norway (Table 1).

STUDY AREA AND METHODS

We defined northern Norway as composed of the three northernmost Norwegian counties: Nordland, Troms and Finnmark (Fig. 1). In this region we marked birds in 12 colonies varying in size from two to 400 pairs (Fig. 1, Table 1). Nine of these colonies had a mixture of fuscus and intermedius/graellsii, while in three colonies only fuscus was breeding (Fig. 1, Table 1). In the mixed colonies there were about equal proportions of the black and grey-mantled subspecies (Table 1). The ringing program started in 2000 for an indefinite time. This study presents resightings from 2000 through early May 2008.

Table 1.

Location of Lesser Black-backed Gull study colonies in northern Norway (see Fig. 1) with information on colony size and composition and marking effort.

t01_281.gif

Adult birds were trapped during the incubation period in late June by using a walk-in nest trap. When caught, the birds were weighed, measured and equipped with alphanumeric colour rings and a metal ring. Colonies were visited a second time in late July to mark fledglings (>∼300 g) with colour rings and a metal ring.

In colonies where both fuscus and greyish-mantled birds were found (Fig. 1), adults were determined to subspecies visually when birds were in the hand. Most birds were easily defined as black-mantled fuscus or greyish-mantled intermedius/graellsii. Juveniles could not be determined to subspecies. All resightings were opportunistic observations by different observers in many countries. Resightings in the breeding colonies are not covered in this study.

Migration routes were classified as eastern or western, with Denmark as a delineation point; birds observed east of Denmark were classified as eastern migrants while birds seen west of Denmark was classified as western migrants. When birds had been observed in more than one year or more than once in one non-breeding season, we selected the observation from the first year following ringing to construct Fig. 2. To classify winter areas we defined the overwinter period as 1 November through 31 March.

Figure 1.

Study colonies of Lesser Black-backed Gulls in northern Norway. Open dots indicate colonies of mixed subspecies while black dots indicate pure fuscus colonies (see Table 1 for additional details).

f01_281.eps

RESULTS

A total of 199 adults and 1284 juveniles were marked with colour-rings between 2000 and 2007. Sixteen (8%) of the adults and 83 (6.5%) of the juveniles were resighted outside the breeding colonies until early May 2008.

Birds ringed as adults

Of the 199 marked adults, 194 were classified to subspecies; 172 fuscus and 22 greyish-mantled birds. Of these, 3.5% of the fuscus and 45.5% of the greyish-mantled birds have been resighted outside the breeding colonies, respectively (P < 0.0001, Fisher exact test). When considering only mixed colonies (Fig. 1), the difference in resighting probability between subspecies was similar (45.5 vs. 4%; P < 0.0012, Fisher exact test).

One fuscus was seen in England and later that winter in Morocco, while another was observed in Portugal (Fig. 2). Evidence of eastward migration came from single birds seen in Israel, inland Central Norway, and in the Baltic Sea. The last bird was observed in southern Norway during spring migration (Fig. 2). Of the greyish-mantled birds, three were found in England, three on the Iberian Peninsula, and single birds in Morocco, Belgium, Italy and Libya (Fig. 2), demonstrating that these birds predominantly have a western migration.

Birds ringed as juveniles

There was a slightly higher probability of resighting juveniles from mixed colonies (7.5%, n = 749) than from fuscus colonies (4.9%, n = 535; χ2 = 4.15, P = 0.048). Juveniles were observed in 20 different countries; 30.1% of the resighted juveniles (n = 83) were classified as eastern migrants (observed in the inner parts of the Scandinavian Peninsula, in Finland, or in countries east of Denmark, Fig. 2), and 69.9% were western migrants (observed in the North Sea area, western Europe, down to western Africa, Fig. 2). The direction of migration was irrespective of the colony type (69.6% and 74.1% of juveniles were western migrants in mixed and fuscus colonies, respectively; χ2 = 0.17, P = 0.68).

Wintering areas

Twenty-nine juveniles from mixed colonies and 13 from pure fuscus colonies were resighted between 1 November and 31 March. The winter areas comprised 12 countries, with 83% of the birds resighted along the western migration route. There was no difference in routes between colony types; 23 (79.3%) juveniles from mixed colonies were found in the area between England/France and Mauritania, two in Italy, two in Israel and one in Cameroon (Fig. 2); from pure fuscus colonies, 11 (84.6%) were found between England and Senegal, while one was observed in Israel and one in Kenya (Fig. 2).

Seven greyish-mantled birds ringed as adults and four fuscus were resighted in winter areas. Birds were seen in western areas between Belgium and Morocco, apart from one greyish-mantled bird observed in Libya and one fuscus in Israel (Fig. 2).

Winter site fidelity seemed high in some of the adults; one of the fuscus was found at the same location in two winters following ringing, while of the six greyish-mantled birds observed in more than one year, five (83%) were seen at the same location. Two birds were observed at the same location in five consecutive years. Five juveniles from the same mixed colony were resighted in more than one winter, and all were observed at the same location; one in Italy, two in France and two in England.

Figure 2.

Resightings (one observation per bird) of Lesser Black-backed Gulls marked as adults (squares) or juveniles (circles) in the study colonies (small circles; Fig. 1) in northern Norway. Black squares refer to fuscus adults, grey squares to greyish-mantled adults. Black circles are birds marked as juveniles in pure fuscus colonies, grey circles are birds from mixed colonies (see Table 1). Black triangles denote previous recoveries of fuscus from Norway (from Bakken et al. 2003).

f02_281.eps

Summering areas of sub-adults

Thirteen one-year old birds (seven from pure fuscus colonies and six from mixed colonies; 1% of all marked juveniles) were resighted in summer (May to August). All birds were observed in western Europe, from Finland in the north to Belgium in the south. Of 246 juveniles colour ringed in a pure fuscus colony in 2005, four were observed in the summer of 2007; one in England, one in southern Norway and two in Finland.

DISCUSSION

This study is the first to document the migration patterns and wintering areas for different segments of the Lesser Black-backed Gull population in northern Norway. Greyish-mantled adults had a ten times higher probability of being resighted on migration or in winter than fuscus adults. The most likely explanation for this striking difference is that fuscus adults move to areas with few observers or stay in habitats where they are less likely to be observed, e.g. off-shore on freshwater lakes in eastern Africa. This is in accordance with the migration behaviour of fuscus from the Baltic Sea (Cramp & Simmons 1983, Kilpi & Saurola 1984, Kube et al. 2000, Hario et al. 2004, Bønløkke et al. 2006). There is also evidence of different migration routes and winter areas between fuscus and greyish-mantled birds from contaminant profiles; i.e. the ratio between DDE (a DDT metabolite) and PCB was higher in fuscus than in greyish-mantled birds (Bustnes et al. 2006), suggesting that the former were wintering in areas where DDE was the dominating compound, as in eastern Africa (Hario et al. 2004; Bustnes et al. 2006). Our resightings were too scarce to be conclusive about the migration route and wintering areas of adult fuscus as only one bird was seen along the eastern migration route (in Israel), and several individuals along the western route.

Forty-five percent of the marked greyish-mantled adults were resighted, most of them in western areas. This corresponds well with the previously established migration routes of intermedius from southern Norway and of graellsii from the UK and the southern North Sea (Cramp & Simmons 1983, Bakken et al. 2003, Galván et al. 2003). It thus seems that these greyish-mantled birds, which probably colonized northern Norway in the 1980s (Strann & Vader 1992), are keeping their traditional migration routes, seemingly different from most adult fuscus in the area. This is surprising since fuscus and intermedius/graellsii may be found in mixed breeding pairs (M.H. & J.O.B., pers. obs.).

The larger sample size of marked juveniles allowed to distinguish a clear dichotomy in the migration pattern; 30% of the observed birds were classified as eastern migrants and 70% as western migrants. As we suspect that the resighting probability is much lower for birds migrating to the east (see above) the actual proportion of juveniles migrating east must be higher than our observations suggest. Nevertheless, it is surprising that many fuscus juveniles (74% of the juveniles originating from a pure fuscus colony) had a western migration. This is different from the fuscus population breeding in the Baltic Sea, which has nearly an exclusive eastern migration (Cramp & Simmons 1983, Kilpi & Saurola 1984, Kube et al. 2000, Hario et al. 2004, Bønløkke et al. 2006).

Unfortunately we obtained only few repeated observations of the same juveniles over the years — in fact all five birds ringed as juveniles and resighted in more than one winter were from the same mixed colony. We can therefore not clear conclusions whether juvenile fuscus change their migration pattern from west to east as they grow older. Such a scenario might well be possible if sub-adults and adults migrate separately, and birds adopting the final migration route only at later age (Baker 1980, Galván et al. 2003). For example, Galván et al. (2003) found in the inner parts of the Iberian Peninsula mainly adult Lesser Black-backed Gulls were observed in more than one year, suggesting that young birds were moving to other areas. As we recorded that some adult fuscus followed a western migration route, it might be that these areas offer some benefits to wintering gulls, for example as a consequence of the proliferation of refuse tip and reservoirs in southwestern Europe (Galván 2003).

In conclusion, the nominate Lesser Black-backed Gull from northern Norway seems to have a migration pattern that is different from the pattern of fuscus from the Baltic Sea. Most striking difference is the importance of the western migration route for the Norwegian juveniles. Migration pattern of the northern greyishmantled gulls is similar to the pattern described for intermedius breeding in southern Norway (Bakken et al. 2003) and the more southern graellsii (Cramp & Simmons 1983). More information about the migration routes of the North-Norwegian Lesser Black-backed Gull populations is needed, especially how they utilize the African continent in winter.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

We are grateful to Jörg Welcker, and others for valuable help during field work, and two anonymous reviewers for comments that greatly improved an earlier draft of the manuscript. The study was funded by the Norwegian Directorate for Nature Management and through the Norwegian seabird research program (SEAPOP).

REFERENCES

1.

R.R. Baker 1980. The signficance of the lesser black-backed gull to models of bird migration. Bird Study 27: 41–50. Google Scholar

2.

V. Bakken , O. Runde & E. Tjørve 2003. Norsk Ringmerkningsatlas. Vol 1. Stavanger Museum, Stavanger. (In Norwegian) Google Scholar

3.

K. Bevanger & P.G. Thingstad 1990. Decrease in some Central Norwegian populations of the northern subspecies of the lesser black-backed gull (Larus fuscus fuscus) and its possible causes. Fauna Norv. Ser C, Cinclus 13: 19–32. Google Scholar

4.

J.O. Bustnes , M. Helberg , K.B. Strann & J.U. Skaare 2006. Environmental pollutants in endangered vs. increasing subspecies of lesser black-backed gulls along the Norwegian Coast. Environ. Pollut. 144: 893–901. Google Scholar

5.

J. Bønløkke , J. Madsen , K. Thorup , K.T. Pedersen , M. Bjerrum & C. Rahbek 2006. The Danish Bird Migration Atlas. Forlaget Rhodos A/S & Zoologisk Museum, København. (in Danish) Google Scholar

6.

S. Cramp & K.E.L. Simmons 1983. Handbook of the birds of Europe the Middle East and North Africa. The birds of the western palearctic. Vol III. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Google Scholar

7.

G.A. Crème , P.M. Walsh , M. O'Callaghan & T.C. Kelly 1997. The changing status of the lesser black-backed gull Larus fuscus in Ireland. Proc. Roy. Irish Acad. 97B: 149–156. Google Scholar

8.

I. Galván 2003. Intraspecific kleptoparasitism in lesser black-backed gulls wintering inland in Spain. Waterbirds 26: 325–330. Google Scholar

9.

I. Galván , J. Marchamalo , V. Bakken & J.M. 2003. The orgin of lesser black-backed gulls Larus fuscus in central Iberia. Ring. Migrát. 21: 209–214. Google Scholar

10.

S. Garthe , T. Freyer , O. Huppop & D. Wolke 1999. Breeding lesser black-backed gulls Larus fuscus graellsii and herring gulls Larus argentatus: coexistence or competition? Ardea 87: 227–236. Google Scholar

11.

M. Hario , V. Bianki & V. Zimin 1998. Larus fuscus fuscus. In: H. Kotiranta , P. Uotila , S. Sulkava & S.L. Peltonen (eds) Red Data Book of East Fennoscandia, Ministry of Environment, Finnish Environment Institute & Botanical Museum, Finnish Museum of Natural History, Helsinki, pp 247–249. Google Scholar

12.

M. Hario , J.P. Hirvi , T. Hollmen & E. Rudbäck 2004. Organochlorine concentrations in diseased vs. healthy gull chick from the northern Baltic. Environ. Pollut. 127: 411–423. Google Scholar

13.

M. Kilpi & P. Saurola 1984. Migration and wintering strategies of juvenile and adult Larus marinus, L. argentatus and L. fuscus from Finland. Ornis Fenn. 61: 1–8. Google Scholar

14.

J. Kube , A.J. Helbig , R. Juvaste , K. Pedersen , C. Rahbek & P. Saurola 2000. Hop or Jump: autumn migration strategies of lesser black-backed gull revealed by satellite tracking. Seventh Seabird Group Conference, Wilhelmshafen Germany, March 2000. Google Scholar

15.

S.H. Lorentsen 2007. The national monitoring programme for seabirds. Results up to and including the breeding season 2007. NINA Report 313. (in Norwegian) Google Scholar

16.

K.B. Strann & W.M. Vader 1992. The nominate lesser black-backed gull Larus fuscus fuscus, a gull with a tern-like feeding biology, and its recent decrease in northern Norway. Ardea 80: 133–142. Google Scholar

Appendices

SAMENVATTING

Twee ondersoorten van de Kleine Mantelmeeuw Larus fuscus broeden in het noorden van Noorwegen. Dat zijn de Baltische Mantelmeeuw L. f. fuscus, die de afgelopen decennia sterk in aantal afgenomen is, en de snel uitbreidende L. f. intermedius/graellsii. Om het trekpatroon van de ondersoorten te onderzoeken zijn vanaf het jaar 2000 meeuwen in 12 kolonies langs de kust van Noorwegen gemerkt met kleurringen met een unieke code. De ondersoorten verschilden sterk in de kans om binnen een paar jaren terug gezien te worden. Voor adulte vogels van fuscus was dit 3.5% (n = 172) en voor intermedius/graellsii 45.5% (n = 22). Dit verschil werd toegeschreven aan de dichtheid van waarnemers die waarschijnlijk hoger is langs de trekroute en in het overwinteringsgebied van intermedius/graellsii (oostelijke Middellandse Zeegebied, oost en centraal Afrika) dan van fuscus (Engeland, de kust van de Atlantische Oceaan, het Iberisch schiereiland, Marokko, Mauritanië en Senegal). Van de 83 waargenomen vogels die als jong waren geringd, en waarvan daarom niet altijd bekend was tot welke ondersoort ze behoorden, werd 30% langs de oostelijke trekroute waargenomen, en 70% langs westelijke route. De herkomst van de jongen (afkomstig uit pure fuscus of gemengde kolonies) had geen effect op de verdeling, wat er op wijst dat het strikte verschil in trekroutes tussen ondersoorten zieh pas op latere leeftijd ontwikkelt. (DH)

Morten Helberg, Geir H. Systad, Ingve Birkeland, Nils H. Lorentzen, and Jan O. Bustnes "Migration Patterns of Adult and Juvenile Lesser Black-Backed Gulls Larus fuscus from Northern Norway," Ardea 97(3), 281-286, (1 October 2009). https://doi.org/10.5253/078.097.0303
Received: 15 October 2008; Accepted: 1 March 2009; Published: 1 October 2009
JOURNAL ARTICLE
6 PAGES


Share
SHARE
KEYWORDS
dispersal
gulls
migration
Norway
site fidelity
RIGHTS & PERMISSIONS
Get copyright permission
Back to Top